Showing posts with label Teresa. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Teresa. Show all posts

Friday, 16 March 2012

Labeling Effects

Looking Glass Self: We see ourselves through the eyes of other people, even to the extent of incorporating their views of us into our own self-concept.

Labeling is something we all do for other people, and for ourselves. It's related to stereotypes, confirmation bias, self fulfilling prophecy, and all other theories involved with the concept of identity.

Many of us know the harmful effects of it, and the good effects of it. While I do not believe that it is good to admonish all these, one should never use it to cloud our judgement on other people. Like how in the case of 911, anyone viewed as "dark skinned" are terrorists regardless of country of origin etc.

In self-fulfilling prophecy, it states that if you believe that you are so and so, you eventually do become so and so. This can go negatively and positively; If you believe you are going to ace a test, there is a higher chance you will. Think you are going to be late, and you'll be late.

I think that one of the situations that causes a high potential "harm" of negative labeling would be when (related) adults label children, like family members and relatives. Every person started out as a young kid under the protection of their family. Their family members are their first taste of human interaction, communication, and their mini "society". I think you can see what I am getting at.

There has been a common trend of calling people either introverts or extroverts. Society seems to depict introverts as shy, quiet awkward antisocial people, while extroverts are like social butterflies ready to try everything under the sun. I feel that a lot of people underlying believed that extroverts are more favourable in most situations, and we should get rid of that notion because introverts are not a "negative" trait.

According to this article, a more accurate way of seeing the difference between an introvert and an extrovert is to see "how these children react to stimuli".

"When these children are at four months, if you pop a balloon over their heads, they holler and pump their arms more than other babies do. At age 2, they proceed carefully when they see a radio-controlled toy robot for the first time. When they’re school age, they play matching games with more deliberation than their peers, considering all the alternatives at length and even using more eye movements to compare choices. Notice that none of these things — popping balloons, toy robots, matching games — has anything to do with people. In other words, these kids are not antisocial. They’re simply sensitive to their environments."

Again, I stress the importance of labeling such kids as introverts with a "negative" connotation as anti-social. If one believes that their kid is shy and has difficulty forming friendships with kids more, if affects the way one treats the child, and through a combination effect of the looking glass self and the self-fulfilling prophecy, the kid really might grow to become an antisocial kid.


Also, on an unrelated note, I thought this study is quite interesting...

If you believe that a medication would work on making you feel better, science proves that you actually can get better. A study showed that by using the correct colour associated to cure (blue colour), regardless of all these placebo medication, there is a higher percentage of people who said their symptoms of pain were gone. The research even went deeper to prove that indeed, there was a higher trend of people who really were cured.

Watch Your Words

Words affect everything. We have learn that if you phrase your speeches in line with what the audience wants to hear, the reception to your speech will be more favorable. Likewise, in surveys, tiny changes to the wording can alter opinions. That is why surveys regarding politics are always so particular about it.

For example, in a study, surveys were sent out to voters before an election. One side received a question if it was "important to vote". The other side received the question asking if it was "important to be a voter." With this, people who read the word "voter" were 14 percent more likely to vote on Election Day.

Perhaps by using the word "voter", it causes people to identify themselves with it, resulting in action done. Perhaps the word "vote" sounded like a command for people to do, and people felt less inclined to do so. As phrased nicely, "One was about a simple action, the other was about being a type of person."

Another example would be a health care debate. Organizations conducted polls to see how much of Americans supported a "public option" for their health insurance plans. One was called, "government administered health insurance plan", the other "government-run health insurance plan". 66% support goes to the former, and 44% to the latter. Even though we do not know how such large government organization system works, it is quite obvious which one we would prefer too. "Administered" sounds as if the government are helping us (and giving us what we deserve), while "run" just sounds like another clinic that we have to go and request for services and pay up.

I am sure that context matters all the time, but these experiments just goes to show how one word can easily alter opinions. As we continue to take on more modules, we will have opportunities to create lots of surveys for our projects and research, so we have to actually put more thought into phrasing our questions. We have to be very mindful and avoid traps such as leading questions, like those questions that ask if you have a problem and you need help with it, therefore if I introduce you to a solution, you cannot say no.

Monday, 20 February 2012

How often do we assume ladybugs are female?

Recalling Chapter 4 on the spoken language, we learnt that language affects the way we see the world. Focusing on this point, I went to dig around the Internet, and found several studies which I thought were really interesting.


1. Language shapes colour perception

"Different languages divide up the color continuum differently: some make many more distinctions between colors than others, and the boundaries often don't line up across languages."

You might have experienced this quite often. Like how I would describe our UB tee as blue, but my friend who studied design comes waltzing in and tells me it's navy, or palatinate, or cobalt. Or something.



"BLUE. Why are you being so picky about this?!"


But that is just English. What about languages that have lesser terms for colours?

Example. Here be colours.



To most of us, we know that they are orange, pink and red respectively. But to people from the Himba tribe, they call all these "serandu". To put this into perspective, give them a red card, they say it's "serandu". Give them an orange card, and it's "serandu" as well. They can see that they are different if you put them next to each other, but show them separately, and they might confuse them to be the same card.

To make things more interesting, if you teach them new names for the colours, they are able to learn how to identify the different shades in the future even without any comparison.

Let's go back to different shades of blue (again, haha). To an English speaker, all shades of blue are called "Blue". But in Russian, there is no such single term that categorises all shades we term as blue. They have this different terms between light blue (goluboy) and dark blue (siniy). Due to having more words for different shades of blue, Russians are better than English speakers in visually discriminating shades of blue.


Nooooooo they are all blueeeeeeeee.


2. Language determines your navigational ability

If I tell you to give me directions, you would often use words like, "left", "right", "in front", "behind" etc. Most of these terms are relative to us. A typical string of directions would be, "turn left (from where you are) at the end of the block", "go forward (from here) and then turn right at the corner"

But for Aboriginal people, they give directions with Naughty Elephant Spray Water cardinal-direction terms aka North South East West. For everything. Directions become "Go southwest, then head Northeast to the west". Telling them that they have something on one of their legs, and you have to say "There's something on your southeast leg."

Tell them to come over and sit with you, and it will be "Hey, take your bags and come sit to the northnorthwest."

This means that for Aboriginal people, they must stay oriented at all times without the help of a compass or a smartphone with 3G capability. English speakers rely on language that uses relative reference frames (i.e. Your left is my right), whereas Aboriginal people uses absolute reference frames (North will always be North. Turn 180 degrees from North, and it's South) This results in Aboroginal people being better navigators than English speakers, even in unfamiliar territory, because they are just so much better at staying oriented and keeping track of where they are.

Now for another interesting bit: Imagine if you never had a "left" in your vocabulary. Will it still affect the way you navigate?

The answer is yes.

A group of deaf schoolschildren invented their own sign language in the 1970s. In the early stages of developing this language, they did not have terms for "left" and "right". Even though all their senses function the same as us, not only they are having extreme difficulty explaining space, they have difficulty figuring out where things are too. In a study, an item was placed at the corner of a room, and they were told to direct a fellow person to the item. The result was that because of the lack of certain linguistic codes for space such as "left of", they have more difficulty internalising a mental map of the room and orientate themselves properly.

---------

In several of these links, they mentioned that language shape how we perceive space, time, colors, and objects. If you search around, studies have found that language can also affect people in more profound ways such as "constructing events, reason about causality, keep track of numbers, understand material substance, perceive and experience emotion, reason about other people's minds, choose to take risks, and even in the way they choose professions and spouses." (Google around. Examples are everywhere!)

This all ties back to how language is arbitrary, how it shapes the way we think and view the world, and even our lifestyle. They all support the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis in which it suggests that the structure of a language affects the ways in which its speakers are able to conceptualize their world, like how the ability to recognise colours comes with having names for them. It brings a whole new deep meaning to the point in our slides that says, "Language is a kind of knowledge."


This is the end of my long-winded entry. For those who are bored, I give you some fun. This has got nothing to do with communications, but well..

Munsell Hue Test

My eyes just died. But at least I have a victory.




I took ages completing this. Glad that this doesn't have a timer. I had to keep leaning back and forth. Blue-Green row was the hardest for me; I was working on the blue side, then by the time I reached the green bit, they all looked the same to me HAHAHA.